The Wrong Elara — book cover

The Wrong Elara

35K+ reads
Mafia Romance Enemies to Lovers Dark Romance Mystery Romance Protector Romance Dual Identity

Elara Voss is used to being invisible—until a mafia kingpin kicks down her door with a murder file that says she’s a legendary traitor. The dossier belongs to another Elara Voss, a dead woman who supposedly betrayed three crime families thirty years ago. Elara wasn’t even born. But when a brutal copycat attack mirrors the old crime, the message is chillingly clear: someone wants history to repeat itself, and Elara is their chosen ghost. Dante Rinaldi, newly crowned don, doesn’t believe in coincidence. He takes Elara as his unwilling “guest,” turning her into a fake informant in a dangerous game to expose the real conspirators. Locked in his gilded cage, Elara learns to weaponize the infamous name that should have ruined her—and Dante finds his ruthless control slipping every time she defies him. As rival families circle and buried lies ignite a new war, Elara and Dante must decide what they’re willing to burn down: a bloody legacy built on fear, or the fragile, forbidden trust growing between them.

Free Preview

Chapter 1

By the time the knock came, I was halfway through translating a divorce decree and halfway through a jar of supermarket pasta sauce.

It was one of those knocks you feel in your teeth—three sharp impacts that rattled the thin door, shook the frame, sent a dusting of plaster down over the dead spider in the corner.

Nobody knocked on my door like that.

I froze, spoon suspended over the saucepan, tomato sauce dripping back in a slow red thread. The city hummed faintly through the cracked kitchen window—distant sirens, a motorcycle racing somewhere above its pay grade, my upstairs neighbor arguing with someone on the phone. Ordinary noise, wrapped around a knock that wasn’t.

I told myself it was a delivery at the wrong address. A drunk neighbor. Anything reasonable.

The second round of knocking wasn’t reasonable.

“Ms. Voss.” A man’s voice, low and crisp, cut through the flimsy wood as if it wasn’t there. “Open the door.”

The hairs at the back of my neck stood up. No one called me Ms. Unless they were emailing me to pay an overdue bill.

“Wrong apartment,” I called back, my voice thinner than I wanted it to be. “Try next door.”

Silence. Then the metallic slide of a lock pick, or maybe a key. I didn’t own a deadbolt good enough to tell the difference.

Adrenaline hit me so hard my knees went weak. I grabbed my phone off the counter with a sauce-slick hand, thumb fumbling for emergency call.

The door burst inward before I reached it.

The man who stepped into my tiny hallway boomed larger than the space itself. Dark suit, darker overcoat that brushed the scuffed floor, and a presence that felt like a shadow swallowing the light. Two other men flanked him, both armed—guns holstered under open jackets, professional stillness in their shoulders.

The central man’s gaze landed on me, moved once down my body—bare feet, leggings with a bleach stain on one knee, oversized university hoodie—and came back to my face. Calm, assessing. Too calm.

“Call that number and you’ll get a dispatcher who hangs up the moment she hears your name,” he said in Italian.

My brain did what it always did: translated automatically, cleanly, even while everything else inside me scattered like dropped glass. I switched to English because it was distance, a tiny bit of control.

“You can’t just break into—”

“Actually,” he cut in smoothly, now in accented English, “I can.” He lifted a slim black folder, as if that explained everything. “Elara Voss?”

Hearing my name in that voice, in that room that suddenly felt too small for air, made something twist low in my stomach. It wasn’t attraction. It was recognition.

I’d seen his face before. Everyone with a television had.

“You’re—” The word stuck.

His mouth curved, not quite a smile. “Dante Rinaldi.”

The name settled over the kitchen like another presence. The new head of the Rinaldi family. The sort of man who showed up on the news standing beside covered bodies and unmarked vans, flanked by lawyers or priests.

I was very suddenly, very awake.

“You’ve got the wrong person.” My voice steadied around the one thing I was sure of. “I don’t know you. I don’t know anyone like you. You need to leave.”

He stepped fully into the apartment, taking in the chipped cabinets, the pile of language textbooks stacked under the table to balance the leg, the glow of my aging laptop on the couch. His eyes were a dark, unreadable brown, framed by lashes too long for a man so unapologetically dangerous.

“No,” he said simply.

One of the guards closed the door behind them with a quiet click. The small sound made my lungs seize.

“Look,” I tried again, clutching the phone like a talisman. “I’m a translator. I work from home. I have exactly two potted plants and one of them is dying. I am not whatever you’re looking for.”

“On the contrary.” He set the folder down on my wobbly kitchen table with almost reverent care. “You are exactly what I’m looking for.”

The folder was thick. Old, the leather softened and scarred, corners dulled by years. A faint, metallic scent drifted up as he opened it, cutting through garlic and cheap tomato.

He slid out a photograph and placed it in front of me.

The woman in the grainy image leaned against a car, cigarette between two fingers, eyes narrowed as if the camera offended her. Dark hair pinned up messily, high cheekbones, a mouth like a secret. The fashion was wrong—the photo had the washed-out tones of another decade—but her face was a ghost in my own bones. Older, sharper, but familiar in a way that made my skin prickle.

Under the photo, in black ink: ELARA VOSS.

My hand tightened around my phone until plastic creaked.

“I’m twenty-seven,” I said. “That picture is—what, the eighties? Nineties? She isn’t me.” My pulse thudded in my ears. “She’s dead.”

“Yes.” Dante’s gaze didn’t leave my face. “Executed for selling out three families. After orchestrating a massacre that killed twenty-three people.”

Words I knew, stories whispered in the news, in crime documentaries playing quietly in background bars: The Voss Bloodbath. The Woman Who Burned the City. The Traitor.

I’d heard the name before, always with a half-lurid fascination. Elara Voss. Like a ghost story told in my own name.

“You think I don’t own a calendar?” I snapped, anger slicing through fear like a cleaner current. “She died before I was born.”

He inclined his head, as if conceding a point in a game. “She did.”

“Then—”

“But names are rarely accidents in my world,” he said. “And copycats even less so.”

He fanned out more photos: crime scene shots printed on glossy paper, the edges curling. A warehouse, blackened and gutted. A bar, chairs splintered, blood dark on the floor. A car shell, twisted by fire.

“The attack last week in San Pietro,” he continued. “The bar outside the docks. You saw the news?”

“I don’t watch the news.” Couldn’t, most days. Too much noise, too much helplessness in other people’s tragedies.

He gave me a look that said he thought I was lying. “The pattern is identical. The message left in Moretti territory, the timing, the victims chosen.” His finger tapped one photo—charred beams framing a spray-painted phrase on the surviving wall. Even through the soot, the words were clear.

ELARA LIVES.

My stomach lurched.

“I’m not her.” I hated the faint tremor that slipped into my voice. “I didn’t even know she existed until…until I was a teenager and a teacher made a joke about my ‘unfortunate namesake’.”

“That’s what you told Marcus?” he asked.

My gaze flicked to the guard on the left. He watched me with pale, unreadable eyes, a scar curving from his jaw into his collar. Marcus, apparently.

“You’ve been watching me?” Heat crawled up my throat, collided with nausea. My apartment suddenly felt even more exposed, every shabby corner something they’d seen.

“For three days,” Dante said. “Since the first message. We track anomalies. A woman with that name showing up on a tax registry, after we were all told the bloodline had died out? That’s an anomaly.”

Bloodline.

“No,” I said automatically. “No, my parents—my parents are from Novara, they—”

“They adopted you,” he interrupted, not unkindly, but without apology. “At six. From a private clinic that no longer exists.”

The room tilted. “How do you—”

“We know everything that matters,” he said. “Except why someone is killing people to resurrect a dead woman’s legend and signing your name to the bodies.”

The photo with ELARA LIVES stared up at me like an accusation.

My heart pounded against my ribs, each beat a useless fist. “I don’t know anything about this. I swear to you.”

Dante studied me for a long, measured moment. The overhead light was too bright, buzzing faintly; it put a sheen on his dark hair, picked out a barely-there scar cutting through his right eyebrow.

“You’re a translator,” he said. “Italian, Russian, English. Occasional French when the money is good.”

“You’ve read my invoices,” I muttered.

“And your emails. And your messages. You have exactly zero criminal connections, unless we count pirating movies.” One corner of his mouth twitched, not-quite-amused. “Which means either you’re the world’s most patient sleeper agent, or you are truly, spectacularly out of your depth.”

“It’s the second one,” I said. “Obviously.”

His gaze warmed by a degree, which terrified me more than his entrance had. Because suddenly, just for a breath, he seemed almost human, almost reachable. A man, not just a title.

He snapped the folder shut. The sound made me jump.

“Regardless,” he said, “you’re in the middle of this. Whether by design or bad luck, I don’t yet know. But my enemies think you matter. That makes you leverage. A target.”

He nodded once at Marcus. In two steps, Marcus was at my side. His hand closed around my wrist—firm, unhurried, inexorable.

“Hey—” Panic flared, hot and sharp. I yanked, but his grip tightened, not painful, just unbreakable. Sauce smeared across his cuff.

“Sorry,” Marcus said, voice dry, as if we were strangers brushing shoulders on a bus.

“You can’t just take me.” My breath came too fast. The room narrowed to their faces, the doorway, the edge of the table pressing against my hip. “I have work, I have deadlines, I—”

“Your clients received notice that you’re unavailable for the foreseeable future,” Dante said. “You sent the emails an hour ago.”

I stared at him. “No, I didn’t.”

He tipped his head toward my laptop. The screen had gone to sleep; a little green light blinked, steady as a metronome. “We did.”

Rage punched through me, bright and clarifying. “You had no right—”

“I had every right,” he said quietly, and it rolled over me with the weight of a verdict. “Someone is using your name to start a war. If you walk out of this building alone, you’ll be dead in twenty-four hours. Forty-eight if they’re incompetent.”

I swallowed against rising bile. He believed what he was saying. Or he was very, very good at pretending.

“Why should I trust you?” I asked. My voice felt raw, scraped. “You’re…you.”

A humorless huff escaped him, gone as quickly as it came. “You shouldn’t.” His eyes locked on mine, steady, unwavering. “But the people coming for you will not offer you a choice. I am.”

Marcus’s fingers loosened a fraction on my wrist, as if echoing the word.

“What choice?” I whispered.

Dante stepped closer. Up close, he smelled faintly of clean soap and something darker under it—gun oil, leather, asphalt after rain. The scent of a world far from my cramped kitchen, and too close now.

“You come with me,” he said. “You let me keep you alive while we figure out who’s doing this and why. In return, you will help me. Play a role. The role they’ve already written for you.”

My laugh came out thin and strange. “You want me to pretend to be her. The other Elara.”

He held my gaze. “I want you to be bait.”

For a second, the room went utterly silent. The hum of the light, the distant traffic, even the arguing upstairs—all of it dropped away.

My skin went cold. “You’re insane.”

“Possibly,” he allowed. “But I’m not the one painting your name in blood.”

He let that sit between us. Somewhere in my body, something small and stubborn pushed up through the fear, as if it had been waiting for an excuse.

“What happens if I say no?” I asked.

He didn’t look away. “You won’t live long enough to regret it.”

The bluntness stole my breath more than a threat would have.

“You’re very sure of yourself,” I said.

“No.” His jaw tightened, the first real crack in his composure. “I’m sure of them.”

He reached into his coat and, for one heart-stopping instant, my muscles locked, expecting cold metal. Instead, he pulled out a slim black device—a phone, unremarkable except for the lack of branding.

He tapped the screen, then turned it so I could see. A live feed filled it: the front of my building, gray and unlovely. A car idled across the street, engine running. Another car turned the corner, slowing.

A third vehicle pulled up behind it. Dark, tinted. Men stepped out. Not his.

I knew that, somehow. Maybe it was the way their heads scanned, the stiffness in their posture. Predators, not protectors.

“This is a bad neighborhood,” I said weakly.

“This is a good ambush point,” he corrected.

On the screen, one of the new men lifted his hand to his ear. Another glanced up at my building, as if he could see me through layers of brick and plaster and fear.

“You have thirty seconds to decide,” Dante said, voice low. No pressure, no hurry—but there was something coiled underneath, a leashed violence that scared me as much as it reassured me.

My life, until now, had been a series of small choices. Safe ones. Quiet ones. Study instead of party. Freelance instead of office politics. Fade instead of fight.

I looked at the screen. At the men, at the cars. At the name someone had painted in fire and blood on a wall I’d never seen.

I thought of my parents—the ones who’d chosen me from a clinic and given me a new last name that had never quite stuck to my skin. I thought of the teacher’s joke, of years of learning to lower my voice, to make myself unremarkable, because the alternative felt like tempting fate.

Fate had found me anyway.

“Fine,” I said, the word ripping out of me like a tear in fabric. “I’ll go with you.”

Relief flashed, sharp and fleeting, across Marcus’s face. Dante didn’t move, but the air around him seemed to thin, tension shifting gears.

“But understand this,” I added, surprising even myself. “I’m not your dead woman. I’m not your legend. I’m not your bait. I’m me.”

For the first time, something like real interest sparked in his eyes, cutting through the ice.

“We’ll see,” he murmured.

He slid the phone back into his pocket, then nodded to Marcus. “Get her in the car. Backstairs. Full cover.”

Marcus released my wrist only to shrug off his jacket and drape it over my shoulders, hiding my face from the side. His hand settled at the small of my back—impersonal, directing.

As they moved me toward the door, Dante paused in my kitchen, gaze sweeping over the saucepan, the open laptop, the half-finished life.

“Do you need anything?” he asked.

It was almost absurd, the question. As if this were a trip. As if I’d be back.

“My notebook,” I heard myself say. “On the couch. And my…my dictionary. The red one.”

Marcus grabbed them without comment, tucking the battered book under his arm, slipping the spiral notebook into his pocket.

I stepped over the threshold of my apartment, heart ricocheting against my ribs. The hallway smelled of old paint and someone’s burned dinner, ordinary and stale. Behind us, another knock—softer, wrong—echoed from the front entrance downstairs.

Dante moved ahead, his shoulders impossibly broad in the narrow stairwell. As we descended into the dim, the air cooling around us, one thought pressed against the inside of my skull, insistent and wild.

I had wanted, once, for my life to matter.

I hadn’t understood what that wish might cost until the wrong man with my name’s ghosts came to cash it in.

At the bottom of the stairs, just before the door to the back alley, Dante glanced back over his shoulder, his gaze finding mine in the shadows.

“Stay close, Elara,” he said softly. “From this moment on, everyone is watching you.”

Hooked? Keep Reading

Download Great Novels and continue The Wrong Elara for free. Hundreds more stories waiting.