Annotated in Red Ink — book cover

Annotated in Red Ink

by I.M. Talbery

36K+ reads

Everyone on campus knows Maya Locke’s story—or thinks they do. She’s the literature major whispered about in hallways, the scandal in every group chat, the girl who supposedly slept her way to an A. Maya survives on sharp retorts, late-night drafts, and the certainty that no one will ever bother to see past the rumors. Then a clerical glitch drops her into the mentorship of Dr. Theo Arden, the university’s coldest rising star and its most merciless critic. Theo doesn’t tolerate favorites. Maya doesn’t tolerate pity. Forced into six weeks of one-on-one sessions, they clash over every paragraph, every sideways glance, every assumption. But as her raw, furious pages strip his defenses, and his questions unravel the lie that ruined her, their rivalry turns into something far more dangerous: the first real chance Maya has to reclaim her name—and the one man who risks his own to stand beside her.

Free Preview

Chapter 1

By week three of the semester, the flyers for the Creative Mentorship Initiative had already started to curl at the corners.

I passed one on the English building corkboard, sunlight glaring off the glossy university logo, and resisted the childish urge to draw horns on the silhouetted professor figure.

“Transform your writing with one-on-one faculty guidance!” it chirped. “Build your portfolio! Forge lasting professional relationships!”

Yeah. Hard pass.

I adjusted the strap of my bag higher on my shoulder and kept walking, counting the tack marks from the old posters that used to be there. Visiting poet. Trivia night. Missing bike. Before my face was the unofficial bulletin everyone carried in their heads.

Don’t be alone with her.

The third floor hallway smelled like old paper and lemon cleaner, the kind of institutional sterility that tried way too hard to cover sweat and fear. Classroom doors yawned open as students spilled out, loud, comfortable, deliberately not looking at me. I threaded through them like smoke.

Someone’s laughter broke, then dropped half an octave when they noticed me. A girl nudged her friend. They leaned together, whispering. I caught the word professor and my own last name and the familiar static buzzed behind my eyes.

Instead of reacting, I dug my phone out of my pocket and made a show of scrolling, like I had somewhere to be and people to disappoint.

My inbox notification glared up at me.

SUBJECT: Mentorship Assignment Confirmation

I stopped walking.

No. No, no, no. I hadn’t even applied. I flicked the email open with a thumb that suddenly didn’t feel like it belonged to me.

Dear MAYA LOCKE,

We are pleased to confirm your acceptance into the Fall Creative Mentorship Initiative. You have been matched with:

FACULTY MENTOR: Dr. Theodore Arden

My heart tripped over itself, then slammed into my ribs hard enough that the hallway tilted. I blinked down at the screen again, as if the name might rearrange itself into literally anyone else.

It didn’t.

I knew who he was. Everyone did. Dr. Arden, the department’s rising star: all sharp cheekbones and sharper comments, reviewers’ darling, rumored to read undergraduates’ workshop submissions on the treadmill for extra cardio. He was famous for two things: his devastating critiques and his obsession with ethics.

And he was the one professor who had never, in two years, so much as looked in my direction unless forced to.

“Locke?”

I flinched.

Professor Hart was leaning in the doorway of 312, tie-dyed scarf draped over one shoulder like she’d stepped out of a different building entirely. Her eyes—wide, warm, annoyingly perceptive—flicked to my phone and then back to my face.

“Everything okay?” she asked.

I shoved the phone into my pocket before she could see the screen. “Peachy.”

She raised a brow. “You’re pale.”

“Sterile lighting.” I gestured up at the buzzing fluorescents. “Very flattering.”

Her mouth twitched in that almost-smile she gave me sometimes, like we were in on a joke other people missed. Before the scandal, she’d been the only faculty member I’d considered emailing for advice.

Before.

“Have you checked your email today?” she asked, casual and not at all casual.

“Hypothetically.”

“Hypothetically,” she said, ignoring a pair of students loitering by the water fountain to listen in, “if you were accepted into a program you didn’t apply to, that would be because we had more faculty step up than we expected. We decided to match a few promising students who hadn’t completed applications.”

“Promising,” I repeated, like it was a foreign word.

Her gaze sharpened. “Maya.”

I pulled my bag strap again, feeling the canvas bite into my shoulder. “It’s fine. I’ll opt out. Save everyone some time and whispering.”

She straightened, the loose bangles on her wrist clinking softly. “It’s not an opt-out situation once it’s assigned. Some of the funding is tied to participation rates. But before you panic—he’s a good mentor.”

He.

Of course. Of course this was her.

“You put me with Arden?” The name came out thinner than I meant it to. All air, no armor.

Her expression did something complicated—guilt, stubbornness, hope. “He volunteered for an extra mentee when he saw we had a surplus. I didn’t assign the pairs, but I did…approve the list.”

Continue reading “Annotated in Red Ink” in the app

Download Great Novels to read the full chapter and the rest of the story

More Like This

You Might Also Like

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

A scandal-haunted student and her merciless professor mentor clash over every page. Read this enemies-to-lovers academic romance free online.
I.M. Talbery writes the kind of academic romance that lives in red ink and late-night office hours. From “Annotated in Red Ink” to “The Research Partner Problem,” her stories pair bookish heroines with infuriatingly brilliant rivals, advisors, and almost-mentors — and let the line between them blur in the most satisfying way. Slow-burn, intellectual chemistry, and that very specific thrill of being seen by someone who reads everything you write.
“Annotated in Red Ink” is a academic romance novel that also draws on elements of Enemies to Lovers, and Real Love Romance. Readers will find favorite tropes like enemies to lovers, academia, college romance, campus rivalry, and slow burn woven throughout the story.
You can read “Annotated in Red Ink” for free on the Great Novels app, available on iOS and Android, or on the web at app.great-novels.com. Great Novels is a serialized fiction reading app for women who love academic romance stories — with hundreds of full-length novels across romance, fantasy, and paranormal genres, plus thousands of new chapters added regularly so there’s always a fresh obsession waiting.